USMNT player ratings: Horvath and Pulisic’s penalty heroics decide Concacaf Nations League final in extra time

Getty Images

The United States men’s national team won the inaugural Concacaf Nations League trophy after beating Mexico in the final in extra time on Sunday, 3-2. This game had just about everything as we saw Mexico manager Tata Martino ejected, plenty of goals, beers and projectiles being thrown onto the field, and a physical, heart-pumping 120 minutes in Denver’s Empower Field at Mile High.

But how did each player perform in this one? Here are our player ratings for the match for every starter, substitute and manager.

All ratings are out of 10, and the higher the number the better. A zero would be a first-minute red card. A 10 would be like a dominant hat trick.

USMNT ratings

(GK) Zack Steffen


The opening goal was not his fault at all. Denied Chucky Lozano with a brilliant save early in the first half and came off in the second with an injury.


(DEF) Sergino Dest


Better going forward than defending. He showed off those moves in attack and made Mexico look silly at times. Taken off, surprisingly, in the second.


(DEF) Mark McKenzie


A poor error by the defender, giving it to Jesus Corona for the opening goal. Looked a tad uncomfortable with Mexico’s speed and technical ability at times. Was strong in air though and improved.


(DEF) John Brooks


Was caught way out on the goal and received an early booking. He was really flustered early, and it showed. Kept his composure though and was a leader at the back.


(DEF) Tim Ream


A surprise inclusion to the starting XI and did nothing to warrant another start. Was drawn out and beaten time and time again. Played 82 minutes more than he should have.


(DEF) DeAndre Yedlin 


Effort was there and recovered well on the opener. His pass back to McKenzie wasn’t poor by any means. Showed great energy and heart.


(MID) Weston McKennie


⚽ 82′ Set up the first goal with his head and deservedly got the second with a brilliant header goal. The star of the team and the leader that was needed.


(MID) Kellyn Acosta


Sloppy in the middle as his passing was off early, but he held his own for the most part. Moved to left back later on and was serviceable. 


(MID) Christian Pulisic


⚽ 114′ (PK) 15 touches in the first half. But he came to life late, winning the penalty kick and converting it to claim the trophy. Wasn’t super busy but stepped up when needed.


(FWD) Gio Reyna


⚽ 27′ Delivered with a goal by being in the right spot at the right time in the box, and he also tracked back deep and defender with everything he had.


(FWD) Josh Sargent


Drifted out wide more than I would have liked, especially when he needs to be a reference point in the box.


Timothy Weah

Dest (60′)

Looked lively on the right but would have liked to have been more involved. A solid showing. He just needs more minutes.


Jordan Siebatcheu

Sargent (68′)

Was the hero of the semifinal but did not factor off the bench much at all as the ball rarely was played into the box when he was there.


Ethan Horvath

Steffen (69′)

Born and raised just 30 minutes from Mile High, Horvath had a lovely save in the final minute of regulation on Lozano and then earned star status in extra time with the penalty save. He’s an American hero with an absolutely brilliant showing in relief for an injured Steffen.


Sebastian LletgetReyna (82′)Held the ball well and was fairly sharp in his passing. Showed a ton of heart in defending.6Tyler Adams Ream (82′) The team just felt instantly more organized when he came on, and his pace was huge to close down on the wing.7

Gregg Berhalter


A character test that started off poorly. He didn’t wait so long to make the changes and showed he is willing to adapt and make the tough calls. Taking out Dest was a bit confusing, but you can’t deny the result. These guys seem to love him, and this could be a huge stepping stone.


Latest news